Workshop on Developments and Patterns of Migration Processes in Central and Eastern Europe
25 - 27 August 2005 in Prague, Czech Republic
The
Multicultural Center Prague and
Faculty of Humanities of Charles
University in Prague held a three-day workshop on 'Migration
Processes in Central Eastern Europe'. It brought together a hundred
participants to discuss current migration patterns and related social processes in Central
and Eastern European countries (CEE). Together we engaged in debates about migration
theories, discussed empirically based accounts from the "region", and listened to
experiences of non-governmental representatives concerned with various aspects
of migration processes in CEE. After the workshop, we made a selection from the
papers and released a publication entitled
Migration Processes in Central and Eastern Europe: Unpacking the Diversity. It is downloadable at the following addresses:
(lower resolution version, pdf, 474 kB)(high resolution version, pdf, 3,4 MB)
Additionally, the initiative is envisaged as the first step towards
long-term cooperation of migration analysts and experts, thus creating
an interdisciplinary network for a dynamic dialogue. The main
coordinator - the Migrationonline section of the Multicultural Center
Prague - specializes in providing information and analyses of migration
processes and policies in the Czech Republic and other (not only)
Central Eastern European countries. Its website
www.migrationonline.cz shall serve as the platform for the future cooperation. This workshop was organized with the generous support of the
Open Society Fund Prague within the framework of the East East Program and
UNHCR Czech Republic.
Call for papers
Application and registration
Updated!
Panels, seminars and topics of presentations.
Deadline for submitting abstracts is 15 JUNE 2005!
Call for papers (.pdf file)
We invite both young and more experienced specialists to submit an
abstract of their presentation for the afternoon seminar sessions of
the "
Workshop on Developments and Patterns of Migration Processes in Central and Eastern Europe" before 15 June (see description below).
Basic guidelines on your paper
- You will have fifteen minutes for your presentation in the seminar.
- We will be expecting that you send to migrace@mkc.cz and to the coordinator of your session either your paper (max. 3000 words) or a detailed description/outline of your presentation by August 15.
- After the seminar selected papers will be published at the Migration Online website. We plan to publish them in the form of an online publication that may be circulated and publicised easily. For an example of such a publication see the proceedings from the seminar on Social and Cultural Diversity in Central and Eastern Europe.
- The coordinator(s) of each session in which you will be
presenting might get in touch with some of you to rephrase some of the
questions and focus of your paper so that it fits withing the overall
frame of the session.
- Each presentation should have one clearly formulated problem/issue
that should be described in concrete terms. There should preferably be
one to three questions that would be connected to the issue and that
would be discussed during the debate. These should not be just
rhetoric. The questions might be formulated together with the seminar
chairman/chairwoman. Please, note that the format of each seminar may
differ according to the way it is set up by the coordinator of the
session.
- While researchers are expected to present a paper based on their research, NGO representatives
can also deliver a presentation based on their experiences with
assisting migrants, cooperating and negotiating with governmental
organizations and/or other NGOs, etc. The working language will be
English and there will be no translation provided.
- Would you be preparing a power point presentation, please, let us know in advance.
- If you cite in your paper, please, provide endnotes.
Interested applicants shall write an abstract (not more than 500 words), fill in the registration form, and send it along with their curriculum vitae (including a list of publications if any) to migrace@mkc.cz.
Completed applications are to be submitted electronically at the latest
by 15 June but preferably earlier. Applicants will be notified about
the results of the application by 21 June. Should you have any further
questions, do not hesitate to contact Marek Canek at Multicultural
Center Prague, Vodickova 36, 110 00 Praha 1, Czech Republic, email: mise@mkc.cz, tel./fax +420 - 296 325 345.
Registration fee is 30 EUR. It is payable to the bank account of
the Multicultural Center Prague (Multikulturní centrum Praha), (IBAN)
CZ46 0300 0000 0004 8296 8953, SWIFT CODE (BIC): CEKO CZ PP PRA, name
of the bank: CSOB, bank code: 0300, variable symbol: 55552.
Participants invited through the framework of the East East program and non-EU citizens from Central and Eastern Europe are exempted from the registration fee. Other participants may ask to be exempted from the registration fee upon consideration.
The expenses (travel, accommodation, meals, etc.) of 16 selected
participants from CEE countries (Belarus, the Czech Republic, Hungary,
Moldova, Poland, Romania, Slovakia and Ukraine) will be covered from
the East East Program of the Open Society Fund Prague.
While some of these participants have already been selected we are
still looking for East East program participants (an expert and/or a
representative of an NGO) from Belarus, Moldova, Poland, Slovakia and Ukraine. The deadline for these applications is 8 June.
Accommodation: Can be arranged by the organizers in the hotel (15 EUR
per person/a night in a double room) or dormitory facilities (7 EUR per
person/a night) of the Charles University.
Panels, seminars and topics of presentations
Program of the workshop
There are the following three morning panels and seven afternoon seminars. The afternoon sessions will run PARALLEL to each other. The program and the topics of presentations are below or can be downloaded above.
- Thursday 25 August
Panel on Migration patterns and policies in Central and Eastern Europe
Seminars:
Integrating gender, class, ethnicity and age into the studies of migration
The impacts of migration on local social structures: 'receiving' and 'sending' settings, urban and rural, international and national
Migration policies and migrants' practices
- Friday 26 August
Panel on Reception of refugees in Central Eastern Europe
Seminars:
Refugees in Central and Eastern Europe: reception, integration and various institutional responses
Borders and borderlands of the European Union
Migration management: the role of non-governmental organizations, experts and researchers
Comparing forms of migrants' exclusion and inclusion in Central
Eastern Europe: from citizen(-ship), denizen, asylum-seeker to
foreigner, alien and illegal
- Saturday 27 August
Panel on Socio-Anthropological challenges for studying migration
Conclusions
PANELS
A) Migration patterns and policies in Central and Eastern Europe, Thursday 25 August, 9.45 - 12.30
The migration patterns within, to and out of Central Eastern Europe
(CEE) will be sketched out in this panel. The migration realities in
the CEE have been described by terms such as circular or incomplete
migration, ethnic diasporas, petty traders, open-air markets or client
system. We aim to discuss the conceptualisations of this part of the
European migration space. This attempt, however, is not meant to lead
to the construction of yet another specificity of this part of Europe.
Since the 1990s, countries such as the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland
and Slovakia have been characterised as a "buffer zone". Do they still
perform this function for certain migrants? Does the concept of the
"buffer zone" express adequately the current migration realities of
Central and Eastern European countries and what are the debates,
policies and interests that create the basis for the continuation of
its use in both academic and migration policy debate? Only some
countries of Central and Eastern Europe joined the privileged
political, economic and a free movement zone (although not yet fully)
and some have remained outside. Consequently the question of the role
of the states that were left behind the new EU eastern border in the
European management of migration may be raised.
In migration literature, the European integration process has been
identified as central for the understanding of growing restrictions and
institutionalisation of migration policies in CEE. The application of
the EU acquis has been negotiated in each national setting and a
certain kind of regulation of migration has been established by
different actors involved. Conditions have been set for migrants to
come, work and stay in the new member states of the EU. Patterns of
integration but also of exploitation of migrants have been emerging.
Session coordinator: Marek Canek
Speakers:
- Dusan Drbohlav, (Faculty of Science, Charles University, Czech Rep.): Overview of migration processes in East Central Europe; Current migration policy of the Czech Republic.
- Dumitru Sandu, (University of Bucharest, Romania): Patterns of temporary emigration: experiences and intentions at individual and community levels in Romania.
- Endre Sik, (ELTE, Department of Ethnic and Minority Studies, Hungary): discussant.
- Darius Stola, (Warsaw University, Center for Migration Research, Poland): What does migration policy respond to? The evolution of Polish immigration policy.
B) Reception of refugees in Central Eastern Europe, Friday 26 August, 9.30 - 11.00
Most Central and Eastern European countries joined the 1951 United
Nations Refugee Convention and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status
of Refugees in the first half of the 1990s. Turning from predominantly
refugee-sending countries into the countries of transition and
destination, they have not been among the most generous receivers of
refugees. The region has been labelled as a "buffer zone"' or a
"waiting room" which holds migrants unwanted in the EU. Moreover,
asylum and immigration policies have represented some of the main areas
of EU harmonization process in the new accession countries from Central
and Eastern Europe. An influx of refugees was expected after the
accession to the European Union in 2004. However, the numbers of
refugees applying for asylum have actually decreased along with
national and EU asylum regulations getting more and more restrictive.
In this panel, we wish to discuss what patterns and developments of
refugee reception and integration could be identified in the region and
how they have changed since the beginning of the 1990s. Moreover, how
did the EU harmonization in the field of asylum policies influence the
current developments and how have the respective countries negotiated
this process? Did it undermine the protection of refugees in the
region? We would also like to open the discussion about the
identification of the countries of Central and Eastern Europe as
refugee receiving countries and to what extent they still perpetuate
the label of a transit country, the country where refugees do not
really intend to stay.
Another question to be raised in this panel is how are various patterns
of refugee reception and integration "imprinted" in refugees'
experiences and everyday survival strategies? And finally, what is the
future research agenda for the research on refugee issues in the
Central European countries?
Session coordinator: Alice Szczepanikova
Speakers:
- Miluse Dohnalova, (Refugee Facilities Administration, Czech Rep.): discussant.
- Barbara Poharnok, (Hungarian Helsinki Committee, Hungary): Reception and integration of asylum seekers in Hungary.
- Martin Rozumek, (Organisation for Aid to Refugees, Czech Rep.): Reception of asylum-seekers in Central European countries.
- Daniel Topinka, (Palacky University, Czech Rep.): The Social Processes in the Asylum Centre - The Prospectors and Theirs Strategies.
C) Socio-Anthropological challenges for studying migration, Saturday 27 August, 9.00 - 11.00
Despite recent growth in attention being paid to migration phenomena in
Central and Eastern Europe, surprisingly few insights and lessons have
been incorporated from the discipline of social and cultural
anthropology. This has been displayed primarily in the
taken-for-granted uses of the notions like ethnicity, culture, national
identity, citizenship, but also in an often unclear and confusing
application of methodological and analytical tools. This panel will
introduce some general lessons that can be learned from the discipline
characterized by putting the migrants' experiences first and also by
its essentially comparative dimension. Combining these two constitutive
factors sheds some fresh light on the social, spatial and historical
variations and differences in understanding the concepts and categories
used for explaining migration phenomena. It also teaches us that
migration processes can not be understood without relating them to the
rise of modern nationalism, nation-state building and larger
socio-economic transformations of societies in Europe that decisively
shaped them. The socio-anthropological perspectives (so that we have a
reference to our title here) can help us to move beyond the naturalised
equation often made between territory, nation, state and citizen. The
panel will thus address some anthropological challenges for our
understanding of migration processes both from the methodological and
theoretical perspective.
Session coordinator: Jan Grill
Speakers:
- Izabela Kolbon, (Institute of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology, Jagiellonian University, Poland): Poles in New York City: Shifting identities in transnational space.
- Rozita Dimova, (Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology, Macedonia): Duldung Trauma: Bosnians in Berlin.
- Dimitrina Mihaylova, (ISCA, University of Oxford, UK): Mapping borders and mobility as transformations of political subjectivity: the case of Pomaks (Muslim Bulgarians) in South Eastern Bulgaria.
- Petra Ezzedine-Luksikova, (Charles University, Czech Rep.): discussant.
Recommended reading -
Nina Glick Schiller (2003),
The Centrality of Ethnography in the Study of Transnational Migration, Seeing the Wetland instead of the Swamp, in: Nancy Foner (ed.) Santa Fe, NM: School of American Research. Temporary use for educational purposes for the workshop participants with the kind permission of the author of the article.
This article of Nina Glick Schiller offers an overview of the recent contributions that the anthropological studies made to our understandings of transnational migration. After introducing historical development of anthropological studies of migration and some terminological clarifications, Nina Glick-Schiller addresses some of the crucial issues of linking theory and methodology in the migration research. Debunking some common myths portraying ethnography as too concerned with particular 'anecdotic' stories without aiming at larger generalization, the author clearly demonstrates that the approach of building, generating, questioning and re-formulating theory during the research process itself is what makes it a particularly apt tool for the study of transnational migration processes. Scrutinizing the influence of methodological nationalism, which sees nation-states 'as natural units of analysis,' she urges us to re-consider our assumptions and methodologies by looking at migrants as operating within the transnational social fields of social relations.
SEMINARS
1. Integrating gender, class, ethnicity and age into the study of migration
2. Reception of refugees in Central Europe: trends, experiences and challenges
3. The impact of migration on local social structures: 'receiving' and
'sending' settings, international and national, urban and rural
4. Borders and borderlands of the EU
5. Migration policies and practices of migrants
6. Migration management: the role of non-governmental organizations, experts and researchers
7. Comparing forms of migrants' exclusion and inclusion in Central
Eastern Europe: from citizen(-ship), denizen, asylum-seeker to
foreigner, alien and illegal
1. Integrating gender, class, ethnicity and age into the studies of migration, Thursday 25 August, 13.30 - 16.30
In this workshop, we wish to examine the interplay of various vectors
of difference such as gender, class, ethnicity or age and how they are
shaping migrants' experiences of migration at the level of every-day
life. Divisions of class, gender, ethnicity, and age structure
relations among various groups of migrants as well as their contacts
with the majority population will be discussed. We suggest addressing
some of the following questions:
- How are migrants' experiences gendered? Are gender relations and
gender roles in migrants' families and social networks challenged by
the experience of migration and life in exile?
- How are ethnic and cultural identities re-constructed and negotiated in exile?
- What are the most influential representations of migrants, how are
they constructed and how do they shape the host society's approaches
and attitudes to migrants?
- In what ways are migrants' class positions challenged by migration?
How do migrants perceive and negotiate these changes? What strategies
do they employ to improve their social status?
- How are generational relations challenged by migration experiences
within and outside the family? How do migration experiences differ
according to migrants' age and position in the family?
Session coordinator:
Alice Szczepanikova
Presentations:
- Ramona Lenz, (J. W. Goethe-University, Germany): 'Fake' Marriages as a Threat for the Nation - Migrant Sex Workers in Cyprus.
- Alexandra Szoke, (CEU, Hungary): New forms of mobility among Western European retirees: German migrants in south-western Hungary.
- Olha Yarova, (Central European University, Ukraine): The impact of the migration of Ukrainian women to Italy on their families.
2. Refugees in Central and Eastern Europe: reception, integration and various institutional responses, Friday 26 August, 13.00 - 16.30
This workshop is meant to be a follow up to the panel Reception of
refugees in Central Europe. It hopes to integrate the researchers'
accounts of asylum policies and the position of refugees in the region
with the experiences of NGO representatives. We hope to open critical
discussion about current trends in asylum policies in Central and
Eastern European countries, about the role of refugee camps, NGO
cooperation with the governmental bodies, etc.
Most Central and Eastern European countries joined the 1951 United
Nations Refugee Convention and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status
of Refugees in the first half of the 1990s. Turning from predominantly
refugee-sending countries into the countries of transition and
destination, they have not been among the most generous receivers of
refugees. The region has been labelled as a "buffer zone"' or a
"waiting room" which holds migrants unwanted in the EU. Moreover,
asylum and immigration policies have represented some of the main areas
of EU harmonization process in the new accession countries from Central
and Eastern Europe. An influx of refugees was expected after the
accession to the European Union in 2004. However, the numbers of
refugees applying for asylum have actually decreased along with
national and EU asylum regulations getting more and more restrictive.
In this session we wish to discuss what patterns of refugee reception
and integration could be identified in the region and how they have
changed since the beginning of the 1990s.
Besides that, the following questions are proposed for consideration:
- To what extent are Central and Eastern European countries still
transit countries, and do we possibly face intentional perpetuation of
the "transit country" label by the governments that are looking for
excuses to accept only a low number of refugees?
- How are patterns of refugee reception and integration "imprinted"
in refugees' experiences and everyday survival strategies? How do
refugees negotiate changes in asylum policies?
- What is the role of refugee camps in the reception and integration of refugees in Central and Eastern European countries?
- How has NGO assistance to refugees in the region developed since
the beginning of the 1990s? What were the most significant
achievements, problems and flaws?
- Is it a useful strategy to delimit one's research focus based on
the category of "refugees" or should we look for more broad and
theoretical concepts to frame our research agenda? Do we risk
essentialization of "a refugee" as an object of our research?
Session coordinator:
Alice Szczepanikova
Presentations:
- Vladislav Gűnter, (Center for Integration of Foreigners, Czech Rep.) Recognized Refugees in the Czech Republic - NGOs vs. NGOs vs. the State vs. refugees vs....? ….
- Agnieszka Maria Kusz, (Palacky University, Olomouc, Czech Republic): Are all children our children? The protection of refugee children in Poland and Czech Republic in asylum centres and children's homes.
- Kajo Zboril, (People in Peril, Slovakia): Integration Problems of Refugees in Slovakia
- Bartlomiej Tokarz, (Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights, Poland), Country of Origin Information Research as a Prerequisite of Fair Refugee Status Determination.
3. The impacts of migration on local social structures: `receiving' and `sending' settings, urban and rural, international and national, Thursday 25 August, 13.30 - 16.30
This session shall examine migration as a dialectical process of both
re-construction of migrants' identities and changes of and within the
local social structures (of both 'sending' and 'receiving' societies).
The starting premise for such a study of migration must be an
acknowledgement of the fact that before becoming an im-migrant he/she
is above all an e-migrant leaving his/her society of origin. This
duality of a migrant experience must be complemented by detailed study
of these local social and power structures that determine, but are also
significantly determined by, his/her departure or arrival.
Additionally, migrants can exercise a 'long-distance' influence on a
local setting on different levels such as through disseminating various
imaginations about life in exile, or changing the local economic and
social relations by financial and social remittances directed back to
original settings, or materially by bringing different goods, etc.
Migrants' arrivals and their presence in the 'adopted' countries bring
about various transformations of the local 'receiving' settings. This
session will thus look at the interplay between the dispositions and
determining factors drifting people towards migration from local
structures, as well as the experiences following the arrival in newly
adopted country. Migrants' experiences of exile shall be understood
against the backdrop of the changing local social, political and
economic structures. We invite papers discussing processes of social
change based on the impacts of migration on local social structures
from all regions of Central and Eastern Europe.
Session coordinator: Jan Grill
Presentations:
- Neda Deneva, (CEU, Bulgaria): The Role of Ethnicity in the Re-construction of "Home": Internal and International Migration in a Bulgarian Muslim Village.
- Raluca Nagy, (Universite Libre de Bruxelles, Romania): Migration from and to Maramures (Romania) - Practices of settlement.
- Razvan Stan, (Romanian Academic Society, Romania): Socio-economic Impacts of International Labour Migration on Catholic and Orthodox Villages from Eastern Romania. A Comparative Approach.
4. Borders and borderlands of the European Union, Friday 26 August, 13.00 - 16.30
The unreliability of political meanings in border settings and attempts
to fix these meanings by a state, citizens and transnational bodies by
force of migration policy is a theme of the seminar. Legitimization of
external EU borders is not only a one-way process. On the EU level, it
is attended with rhetoric of establishment of a common area of freedom,
security and justice (the Hague Programme) but also national interests
and interests of border regions play a significant role. We intend to
focus on issues of establishing and reification of contemporary eastern
EU border and its local consequences with respect to cross border
migration. On different levels, the session shall critically examine
the rhetoric and practices of the 'opening' of borders on the one hand,
and the increasing patrolling and/or closing of borders by the nation
states towards the potential (un-)wanted migrants on the other.
Organizers welcome papers focusing on the following topics:
- Migration and constitution of the eastern EU border as the border dividing "Europe" and "non-Europe".
- What are the local interests and global arguments involved in this
process? How is migration constructed as an issue of political debates
in borderlands?
- Whether, how and to what extend does the "new" eastern EU border
re-present and re-produce "new" boundaries? Border institutions and
their influence on local short term/ day-to-day migration
Session coordinator:
Jakub Grygar
Presentations:
- Daniela Gutu, (Centre for the Prevention of Trafficking in Women, Moldavia): Another Berlin wall on the Prut River or the consequences of the new EU eastern border on the Republic of Moldova.
- Yaraslau Kryvoi, (Belarusian State University, Moldavia): Challenges to migration policies in Belarus.
- Natalia Parkhomenko, (Center for Peace, Conversion and Foreign Policy of Ukraine, Ukraine): The Ukrainian Labour Migration to the countries of Central and Eastern Europe: the view of the Ukrainian labour migrants.
- Cosmin Radu, (University of Bucharest, Romania): "We are all tourists!" Informal labour markets and socio-economic practices on the Romanian-Serbian border in different migration regimes.
5. Migration management: the role of non-governmental organizations, experts and researchers, Friday 26 August, 13.00 - 16.30
The political project of a 'rational and effective migration
management' in CEE as it is envisioned by different actors in the field
of migration politics, relies not only on the capacities of states and
their international organisations alone but assigns crucial functions
to non-governmental organisations and migration researchers. The
increasing role of non-governmental organisations (NGOs) in
international relations in general and in the field of migration policy
in particular is stated in a variety of publications and contexts. The
growing importance of NGOs is frequently connected with a hope for more
legitimacy and recognition of human rights. Experts and researchers,
working for all actors in the migration field, fulfil a variety of
functions, from data gathering and situations analysis to policy
development. Often migration research as an academic discipline claims
to contribute to a 'better', more 'efficient' or even more 'just'
migration policy.
The workshop shall examine these overly uncritical claims of the role
NGOs and academicians play in migration management. The following
questions are proposed for further consideration:
- What different types of NGOs are there in the migration field and
which different functions did and do they fulfill in the implementation
of a new migration regime in CEE?
- What functions do experts and researchers have in the formulation
of aims and strategies of migration management? What is their actual
role and influence?
- What is the political rationality behind the call for more
policy-relevant knowledge to be produced by migration scholars? Has the
production of such knowledge resulted in "better" migration policies?
- In what ways do the positions of relevant NGOs and mainstream
migration studies differ and resemble the approach that states and
international organisations have on migration management in CEE?
Session coordinators:
Fabian Georgi and
Joshua Hatton
Presentations:
- Olena Burkatska, (Charitable Foundation "Rokada", Ukraine): Rokada's Work.
- Derya Durmaz, (International Catholic Migration Commission, Turkey): An NGO-Government Cooperation Model from Turkey.
- Martin Geiger, (University of Bonn/EUROFOR, Germany): International organisations, the stabilisation and accession process in South Eastern Europe and the Management of Migration.
- Vera Ivanovicova, (Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, Czech Rep.): The Czech pilot project "Selection of Qualified Foreign Workers".
- Petra Klvacova, (Charles University, Faculty of Social Sciences, Czech Rep.):Foreigners in the light of Research: Analysis of Research Reports.
6. Migration policies and migrants' practices, Thursday 25 August, 13.30 - 16.30
The seminar will try to find a new perspective on migration issues.
While the overwhelming majority of migration research and politics
views migrants as the object of observation, control or support it is
important to shift the perspective to incorporate the views and
autonomy of the migrants themselves. In order to assess the impact of
the migration policies and border regulations in Central and Eastern
Europe it is important to know how the migrants perceive and act
towards negotiating and/or subverting them.
Contributors are invited to submit papers that take into consideration
the tensions between various forms of social resources (kinship,
ethnicity, shared poverty, cross-border marriages, reciprocal
transactions between "employers" and "employees" and the reverse,
exploitation), acting from below and the development of an increasingly
restrictive European Union as an area of "freedom, security and
justice", imposed from above. The relative importance of the social
networks is aimed to contribute to various forms of adaptation, while
the strength of transnational dependencies will probably assure a
certain level of continuity in migration.
The participants are invited to propose answers to the following questions:
- What are the migrants' practices? How these practices have changed during recent political and economic transformations?
- How do migrants deal with increasingly restrictive measures and new
developments applied as forms of "managing migration"? How is border
control negotiated and appropriated by migrants?
- To what extent do the various migrants' practices prevent or enable
an establishment of a "rational and effective" system of migration
management in CEE?
Session coordinators:
Cosmin Radu and
Fabian Georgi
Presentations:
- Julia Bernstein, (Goethe University Frankfurt am Main, Germany): Russian Food stores as Transnational Enclave? Coping with the immigration Reality in Israel and Germany.
- Taras Budzinskyy, (Laboratory for Social Studies by NGO "Centre for Private Initiative Support", Ukraine): Protection of the Rights of the Ukrainian Labour Workers in Countries of Western Europe and Russia.
- Oana Ciobanu, (University of Bucharest Romania): Migration Ideologies, Migration Policies.
- Marketa Moore, (University of Hong Kong, Czech Rep.): New Chinese migration to East Central Europe: Comparative perspective.
- An Verlinden, (Ghent University, Belgium): From Migration Control to Migration Management Elements for an Inclusive, Bottom-up Approach towards Worldwide Migration Management.
7. Comparing forms of migrants' exclusion and inclusion in Central Eastern Europe: from citizen(-ship), denizen, asylum-seeker to foreigner, alien and illegal, Friday 26 August, 13.00 - 16.30
In the national order of things, states and their citizens re-produce
certain demarcations of specific categories of who is included, and who
is excluded from national, ethnocultural or local 'communities' or
other social groupings. The formal or imagined membership then give
access to certain rights and benefits and privileges to those
considered as insiders vis-a-vis those labeled as outsiders. The
criteria for selecting these often exclusionary categories, as well as
the ways these are experienced may take different forms. Thus we can
find various socio-historically institutionalized forms of
inclusion/exclusion such as these formally embedded in the institutions
of citizenship or asylum-seeker category, yet also more informal ones
determining everyday practices and ways of seeing the migrants. More
general factors determining the transformation of these categories and
their contents range from changing political systems accompanied by
struggle for political power, competing nationalisms to the radical
socioeconomic transformation of societal order (such as the one
following 1989 in most Central Eastern European countries). These
macro-structural changes bring transformations into the more intimate
spheres of kinship networks and survival strategies that do not have to
be displayed only on the level of international migration from one
state to another but also in the periphery-center, rural-urban
migration processes. We invite papers addressing the processes and
mechanisms through which different forms of exclusion and
marginalization operate as well as the ways migrants oppose them.
Session coordinator: Jan Grill
Presentations:
- Andrea Barsova, (Office of the Czech Republic Government): Nationality, Civic Citizenship and Inclusion in the Czech Republic
- Oleg Chirita, (International Labour Organization): Consequences of Labour Migration for the Republic of Moldova.
- Jan Cernik, (Institute of Ethnology of Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Charles University in Prague, Czech Rep.): Client system.
- Petr Kafka, (Department of Political Science, University of Toronto Canada): Nationality Laws in Central Europe: Is our treatment of immigrants fair or square?
- Hana Synkova, (Institute of Ethnology, Faculty of Arts, Charles University, Czech Rep.): "In the Czech Republic, they call you "sir" - The migration of Slovak Roma as a tactic to overcome exclusion.